Apple has deemed it appropriate to remove the Exodus International app from the Apple App Store. See the Exodus International App Removed From Apple piece for more details.
I favor Apple’s decision, and justify this opinion that opposes Exodus International‘s position with the following discussion.
So how does one resolve these seemingly conflicting premises?
- Homosexuality is a sin;
- Love thy neighbor;
- Love the Lord.
The problem arises when you teach (as does Exodus International) that homosexuality is wrong, because these gay is wrong lessons very often trigger people to over react when they encounter a gay person. In many extreme cases, such teachings incite violence against the gay, who this teaching obviously disfavors. However, at least Exodus International attempts to prevent this over reaction by addressing the gay bullying that targets LGBT community members frequently. Still though, teaching that homosexuality is wrong can provide those predisposed to committing gay bullying violence for a cause, to feel justified in acting with distain and physical menace toward homosexuals. After perusing their web site, I do not believe that Exodus International fully appreciates this grave ramification of their anti-gay publications, and the adverse effects their teachings might have on the problem of gay bullying around the world. Apple on the other hand, seems to have realized this, and took the highly appropriate action of pulling the Exodus International app from their app store.
Besides, who’s to say that God himself didn’t make the homosexual gay? I don’t think anyone has ever heard God himself say that being gay is wrong.
The devout believers claim that God made everything else, right? So why would he not have created homosexuality? This begs the question: Why would Exodus International highly regard some of God’s creations (the heterosexual) while devaluing some of His others (the homosexual)? Perhaps God put homosexuals here to truly test just how loving and compassionate his followers could be. Who knows? If that was what He did, then many folks are failing that compassion test, including in my opinion, Exodus International, even if they offer thier opposition to gay bullying to difuse some of the molevalance of their gay-is-wrong position.
Proponents of the belief that homosexuality is sexually disordered, often claim that homosexuality is just as devient and harmful to society as other behaviors such as incest, pedophilia, and rape. However unlike homosexuality, these crimes always have victims because the perpetrator forces himself / herself on a much weaker person, imposing the will on them. These behaviors probably have genetic components but not excuses, since if left unchecked, they can victimize and wound many in long-lasting ways. To those who would argue that homosexual bullying victims are victimized because of their homosexuality I’d say: The bullying is by no means an inherent result of homosexuality, but rather, an inherent result of unchecked prejudice within those who do the bullying. The problem here rests squarely on the shoulders of the bully; not the homosexual.
Homosexuality however is victimless. When the person being gay is amongst practicing homosexuals, and he or she does not violate some one’s wishes, then there is no victim bullied, abused, dominated, or otherwise. Thus, homosexuality is not in the same class of behaviors as incest, pedophilia, and rape. So it’s incorrect that Exodus International regards homosexuality as a faulty fluke of nature; not to the degree at any rate, that you’d view pedophilia or incest as harmful and in need of excising.
Further, there is a constant war in every one of us between who we actually are, and what we think we should be. When society denounces homosexuality, it intensifies this war within anyone with homosexual leanings. The result is often mental illness, deep despair, dejection, rejection, and so on. Why do people think that they should be so different than who they actually are? Unfortunately, this tendency has made psychotherapists rich, and left most of society mentally ill to one degree or another.
Now, so long as the Christians act to promote their thinking in benevolent ways (by not excluding or otherwise eliminating the gay population), then, while the whole business still leaves a bad taste in my mouth, I could live with it. However I’m not gay either. So perhaps I’m not as sensitive to the gay position as I might otherwise be. I’m sure some gays would probably still object to the notion that homosexuality is wrong no matter how benevolently it’s expressed. But for me to object further, I’d have to have firsthand experience with the gay lifestyle; which I do not. So I’ll stop objecting further for now.
Exodus International and others who think homosexuality is wrong on principle, can express their beliefs all they want, in appropriate venues. But I’m not sure that the iTunes App Store is such a place; particularly where children have easy access and where many customers found the presence of the Exodus International app highly offensive. Maybe if they put the app in the adult content section, I’d feel less inclined to resist it, but resist it I still would.
If Apple was a part of the US government, then I’d surely oppose their censorship of the Exodus International app. But since Apple is a private-sector business, the rules against censorship become way more lax. As such, Apple need not carry anything they wish to ban, and no reason for refusal is necessary either. So, Apple is within its rights to censor this app, and personally, I’m glad that they did.
Now, about that “moral imperative” that Christians have to rid the earth of homosexuality, I’ll look at this Exodus International organization a bit further and read more of just what they’re saying about homosexuality before passing a strong judgment on them. But I’ve witnessed the sorts of oppression that others like them (who justify their anti gay sentiments with religious doctrine) are capable of. Groups such as Exodus International scare me because they act like they know so much. Yet they know not what they know not. This particular group appears to be no different. But I’ll give them a fair shake, but will bail if they make too many claims about the wrongness of homosexuality that they fail to prove.
I’ll admit that much about the origins and motivations of homosexuality is still not well-understood. But that gives no group license to invent ideologies and “moral imperatives” that disfavor a particular sect of the population (homosexuals in this case being disfavored by Exodus International). Such believers shouldn’t act like they know something definitively when in fact, they do not; they cannot.
Already, I’m put off because a basic premise here is that homosexuality is an error, a sin, something to be expunged from humanity, and can be addressed simply by changing behavior. But I can’t make such a big leap of faith; not when the result is so much discord, hurt feelings, exclusion, and discrimination of homosexuals from mainstream society.
At least however, Exodus International admits that they don’t “cure” homosexuality and that they’re only targeting those who harbor “unwanted same-sex attractions” to quote them. I’ll review more of their writings presently.
Lastly, Apple is rich. So they don’t have to seriously consider the financial ramifications of one particular app I don’t think. They can indeed afford to include or exclude based on public feedback, which is what apparently drove them to remove the app from Exodus International. Perhaps they thought they’d lose more money by keeping the app than by getting rid of it.
Tom Hesley
Related Posts
References